In the study group's first year at Greendale, Jeff defends Abed who is being bullied by a student named Mike Chilada. Mike taunts Jeff during his spanish test which causes him to lose his temper and challenges Mike to a fight. Shirley pleads with him not to go through with it since it's Christmas time but he ignores her. Jeff meets up with Mike on the campus quad for the fight but changes his mind wanting to honor Shirley's wishes. When the study group arrives to cheer Jeff on, Mike assumes they are there for back him up and sends his gang after them. As the battle between the two group begins, the song "Kiss With A Fist" is played. The songs was first heard in the Season One episode "Comparative Religion".