Oh, and for the record, there was an episode of 'Happy Days' where a guy literally jumped over a shark — and it was THE BEST ONE!"
|Jeff arrives at Greendale in his battered Lexus for the last day of the school. As he walks across campus, he encounters various people from school and greets them fondly. He runs into Annie who is with her boyfriend Vaughn. She decides to join Jeff as since they are both headed to the study room. Dean Pelton suddenly shows up asking them if they plan on going to this year's Transfer Dance. It's the last dance of the year where they celebrate students who are moving on to four year colleges. Back in the study room, Troy reveals to the group that his father is kicking him out of the house in order to make room for his younger girlfriend. Abed ignores Troy's hints that he would like to move into his dorm room as Jeff and Annie show up.
|Jeff's Lexus is still Chang'd up.
|They announce the news that Britta has benn nominated for the title of "Transfer Queen" at the upcoming dance. Dean Pelton then drops by with the update that the dance has been renamed the "Tranny Dance". Later at Britta's mandated therapy session with Professor Duncan, he encourages her to compete for the title. He thinks it will help her get over some of her psychological hangups. Britta angrily ends the session as Ben Chang, who is now a student, shows up. Britta complains to him about Duncan's suggestion only to be insulted when Chang warns her not to wear to much lipstick like she did at the last dance. After she leaves, Change asks for Ian's help to cheat in his classes. He ends up humiliated when Duncan ruthlessly mocks him instead over Chang's current situation.
|Britta in her last mandatory therapy session with Professor Ian Duncan
|Meanwhile, Jeff bumps into Professor Slater on his way to class. She admits she made a mistake breaking up with him and asks for another chance. The study group later attends a keg party hosted by Abed in his dorm. Troy tries again to drop hints to Abed about moving in with him but is ignored for a second time. Vaughn arrives at the party with some news for Annie. He has just been invited to join the nation's best college hacky sack team located in Delaware. Inside the dorm room, Jeff tries to flirt with Britta who is oblivious. Things become more awkward when Slater joins them and Jeff senses the animosity between the two women. Britta then suddenly announces to Michelle her intentions to run for Tranny Queen.
|Shirley celebrates her first keg stand.
|That night at the Transfer Dance, it becomes clear that Britta and Slater are openly competing for Jeff's affections. At the same time, Duncan continues to taunt Chang mercilessly. Chang has to restrain himself from physically retaliating out of fear that he will be expelled for hitting a teacher. Meanwhile, Annie announces to the group that she will be going to Delaware for the summer with Vaughn. Privately, she tells Jeff that she is not merely going for the summer but intends to transfer to Delaware because she wants to try and live in the moment. Later, Pierce talks to Troy about his living situation and offers to let him to move into his mansion.
|Um, guys? Cleanest face ever.
|At the study room, Troy finds Abed and asks him why they can't live together. Abed replies that living together would put too much of a strain on their friendship. He advises that Troy go ahead and move in with Pierce. Since theirs is a more casual acquaintance, them constantly being together won't put as much stress on their friendship. Troy leaves upset and confused over Abed's explanation. Back at the dance, Britta is preparing for the competition with Shirley's help. Shirley admonishes Britta's actions, telling her that she should stop competing with Slater and just be honest with Jeff about her feelings. Later, Annie says her goodbyes to the group and leaves with Vaughn.
|Vaughn and Annie say goodbye to the study group.
|With everyone's attention drawn to the fight, Jeff quietly exits as both Britta and Slater watch him leave. Meanwhile, Troy becomes sick from eating a giant cookie and finally understands what Abed was trying to tell him: too much of a good thing is sometimes bad. He then accepts Pierce's invitation to move in with him. Outside the dance, Jeff is surprised when he runs into Annie. She explains that despite her wanting to live in the moment, Greendale is where she belongs. After a heartfelt conversation about their respective relationships, Jeff tells Annie that he is glad she's staying and they hug. The two linger for a second afterwards causing Annie to impulsively plant a quick kiss on Jeff. Although stunned for a second, Jeff embraces Annie and kisses her back passionately.
Some students watch a video yearbook by Abed featuring all the main study group members, complaining that they do not know any of these people.
- That just happened: In the previous episode, Chang was revealed to be a fraud as a teacher and now has enrolled at Greendale to get a real degree like Jeff.
- Returning students: This episode sees the return of Garrett, Vaughn, Leonard, Eric, Linda, and Star-Burns.
- Returning faculty: This episode sees the return of Professor Whitman, Professor Duncan, and Professor Slater.
- Familiar face: Actor Matt L. Jones returns as a character known as "Stoner friend". In a previous episode, "Introduction to Film", he played a coffee delivery guy.
- A sweet ride: Jeff's Lexus is still damaged from Chang's assault with his keytar in the previous episode "English as a Second Language".
- Double take: Chang's meeting with Duncan mirrors Jeff's meeting with Duncan in the first episode.
- School supplies:
- Abed is wearing a sword at his kegger which originally appeared in "Communication Studies".
- Throughout the episode, Troy is seen eating a large cookie provided at the school dance.
- School song: Pierce plays the school song at the Tranny Dance, a song he wrote in "Advanced Criminal Law".
- Googly eyes: Jeff's relationships with Slater, Britta and Annie are explored in this episode.
- Discontinuity: Abed's observations about Jeff's relationships with Slater and Britta in the prvious episode "Communication Studies"is retconned in this episode. He had earlier stated Britta was the one motivating Jeff to change for the better and Slater was the one who accepted him as is. Jeff agrees with his assessment but then changes his mind and reverses the two women's roles in this episode. Creator Dan Harmon acknowledged the discrepancy and offered an explanation for it in interview this interview.
- Cliffhanger: The episode ends with Jeff kissing Annie, the repercussions of which are dealt with in the Season Two premiere.
- You're the worst: Shirley's unseen friend is mentioned. Everyone is glad that he is transferring schools.
- Pansexual imp: Dean Pelton's Dalmatian fetish comes to a head in this episode.
- Nice outfit: Dean Pelton's personal ad is answered by two people wearing Dalmatian costumes.
- Visual aids: At the Tranny Dance, Troy is seen eating a giant cookie that gets progressively smaller each time he appears onscreen.
- Alert nerd!: Abed brings up the trope of "Jumping The Shark" when explaining to Troy why they can't move in together.
- Parody: The episode was meant to be a take on teenage soap operas like "Dawson's Creek", particularly the love triangle aspects of those shows.
- Up against the wall:
- Pierce asks Troy, "What happened to us?" This is an overt reference to the fact that the writers had originally intended for Pierce and Troy to be best friends. When the Troy/Abed pairing was shown to have great chemistry, that idea was quickly dropped.
- When Dean Pelton announces the candidates for Tranny Queen, he says the name "Danielle Harmon", a reference to the shows creator Dan Harmon.
- Use your allusion:
- Abed turning off the lights in the study room is a reference to the last episode of "Cheers" when Sam Malone ended the show by turning the lights off in the bar.
- Linda Greene from The Greendale Gooffaws urges Jeff to choose Britta by saying "Team Britta", a reference to the vampire novel series, "Twilight".
- Chang tells Duncan that he will find a loophole and kill him, a reference to "Lost" and The Rules.
- Current events: Star-Burns yells out "Bring Conan back!", a reference to NBC who at the time had removed Conan O'Brien as host of "The Tonight Show." (See IRL)
- IRL: Dino Stamatopoulos (Star-Burns) was a writer for Conan from '93 to '99
Star-Burns in the yearbook.
Troy eating a giant cookie.
Britta tells Jeff that she loves him at the school dance.
Britta talks to Slater at the school dance.
Annie at the school dance.
- “I hope he transfers to hell.”— Troy, after finding out that Shirley's friend Gary is transferring schools.
- “So you think I'd feel better about myself if I got all sexed up, went over there and really tried to be crowned Queen of the Dingbats?”— Britta
- “Precisely.”— Duncan
- “Wow. Guess you really get what you pay for with free therapy.”— Britta
- “Ouch. That stung a little bit. Thanks.”— Duncan
- “Señor Chang, is there a word in Spanish for someone who used to pretend to be a professor but was a teacher but wasn't actually a teacher and is now a student? Is there a word for that? Oh, if it was in Spanish, you wouldn't know, would you?”— Duncan
- “Oh, and for the record, there was an episode of Happy Days where a guy literally jumped over a shark. And it was the best one.”— Troy
- “Jeff needs a girl who doesn't just not wear underwear because Oprah told her it would spice things up. He needs a girl who doesn't wear underwear because she hasn't done laundry in three weeks. He's been to flavor country now. They should retire the table we did it on.”— Britta